Anchorage’s inaction on homelessness

As trash plagued encampments continue to proliferate in our city’s public spaces, it has become clearer than ever that Anchorage’s homelessness problem has reached a crisis level.

Homelessness in our community has spiraled into an undeniable catastrophe. The sight of individuals living in tents scattered across our parks, in front of our businesses, or seeking refuge in our public buildings, has become a shaming, yet defining, image of our community. Anchorage finds itself traveling towards a crucial fork in the road, where decisions made by our leaders, or the lack thereof, will have profound and lasting consequences on the most vulnerable members of our population.

And driving that bus, seemingly straight towards the cliffs of catastrophe, is the Anchorage Assembly. A governing body whose repeated inaction on homelessness has exacerbated the problem to the point of devastation, and left countless Alaskans in desperate and disheartening situations.

The Scope of the Crisis

According to the latest data from the Anchorage Coalition to End Homelessness, published at the end of July, there were 2,940 people actively experiencing homelessness in Anchorage, an unacceptable statistic by any administrative standard. Most of these Alaskan residents, who, due to increasing rent, a shortage of affordable housing, addiction, mental health issues, or some combinations thereof, have found themselves in a dire situation.

When you factor in the geographic context and consider the sledgehammer of extreme weather that winter will surely bring, you can certainly recognize the fact that homelessness in Anchorage is not a mere matter of public discomfort, social inconvenience, or government inadequacy, it is a matter of life and death.

The Irony of Inaction

The first step in solving any problem is admitting you have one, and as a community, I think we can all agree that this is a problem. The irony of our situation is that we also have a fairly good idea of how to solve the problem and, more importantly, who is responsible for pulling us out of the muck of homelessness. Yet, despite the obvious evidence directly in front of their faces (and one that they likely drive or walk pass by on a daily basis), the Anchorage Assembly has displayed a demoralizing pattern of inaction, or at best, half-step measures.

Make no mistake about it, the Anchorage Assembly has both the capacity and the capability to find a solution. It is the Anchorage Assembly, after all, that wields the financial power over budget allocations, the influence in shaping policy direction, and the final approval of any plans aimed at addressing this crisis.

In recent years, its efforts have been largely characterized by hesitation, delay, and political infighting. Various proposals aimed at tackling homelessness have been brought forward, but few have been meaningfully considered or funded to a degree that would yield tangible and vital results. Even now with a new mayor straight from their ranks, we are still seeing the same old.

Winter Approaches—The Clock is Ticking

Each winter, as temperatures plummet and the legacy of inaction persists, the lives of our homeless population are again threatened. There is clearly an urgent need for shelters, yet year after year, the Assembly has struggled to come to a consensus on the locations and funding for these shelters, all while holding the keys to both the budget and the planning resources.

Temporary solutions like using the Sullivan Arena as a makeshift shelter (at a price tag of over $1 million per month), offered only a band-aid approach. While the Assembly wasted time, money, and lives, spinning the next temporary measure. This year being no different, the newest plan from the Assembly is to temporarily place individuals in hotels, to the tune of $9 million. Again, just enough to buy them more time to spin the next temporary measure.

The lack of meaningful progress on homelessness issue is not just a reflection of neglect, but also a series of failed opportunities. In 2020, the Municipality of Anchorage received $156 million in federal funds to provide support to individuals and families in need as the community navigated the challenges brought by the COVID-19 pandemic, a portion of which were earmarked for the development of programs to support “…renters, landlords, home and property owners, and individuals experiencing homelessness.” 

The Assembly let this opportunity slip through their fingers, formulating no lasting solutions.

A Call for Leadership

The Anchorage Assembly must recognize that inaction and political posturing is no longer an option. The city’s homeless crisis is growing, and it is not going to resolve itself. Band-aiding the problem with temporary shelters and half-hearted measures is only serving to kick the can down the road.

What is required is a comprehensive, well-funded approach that addresses the root causes of homelessness, including affordable housing, mental health services, and addiction services. While the causes of homelessness are surely complex, the lack of decisive leadership and the refusal to prioritize long-term solutions is a moral failure that has allowed this crisis to proliferate.

Anchorage needs a bold, compassionate approach to homelessness, one that reflects the values of its residents and ensures that no one is left out in the cold.

Keith is a lifelong Alaskan. He served in the Marine Corps as an Infantryman for five years, then started a software company that got him recognized as “Alaska’s Entrepreneur of the Year” in 2018. He now works as a PA-C, with a Doctorate in Medical Science, providing healthcare to his fellow Alaskans. 

Subscribe
Notify of

64 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Angela Ramirez
11 days ago

Right on!

ART
11 days ago

Nice work, Keith. However, in laying blame entirely on the Assembly you are effectively giving the mayor a free pass. The mayor and Assembly must work together, as neither branch can do much entirely on their own. As you may know from Jeff’s recent Landmine coverage, the mayor’s office said that they will “honor and respect” it when the homeless deny offers of shelter and want to keep camping in the woods. If that is how the mayor’s office is operating, it’s hard to see anything improving much over the next few years. I don’t have much hope at this… Read more »

Keith McCormick
11 days ago
Reply to  ART

The Assembly did their best to not work with the last mayor. I do lay it at the feet of this new mayor as well. I commented how she is from their own ranks, and even still, they can’t come up with a plan that lasts more than a season.

Dan Svatass
11 days ago

What a dishonest op-ed. This piece was published today, September 24. But for some reason, Keith McCormick chose to cite AKHMIS’s homeless count of 2,940 people on July 31. Rather than its most recent count of 2,457 people on August 31. https://www.aceh.org/data Why did McCormick and this site use the old data? Old data that now significantly overstates the current number of people experiencing homelessness in Anchorage? I can’t say for certain. Lazy? Sloppy? Probably not. McCormick’s apparently a veteran. And he apparently has gotten some sort of two-year medical degree. So he plainly has skills. I this the reason… Read more »

Keith McCormick
11 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Believe it or not, I spent time writing this op-ed. I wanted to ensure my words were appropriately expressing my thoughts and intentions. Those numbers stating “as of Aug 31” were not posted on Aug 31, nor by Sept 10. I had gathered my references before they were posted.
The “apparently a veteran,” and “apparently a two-year degree,” are some funny ad hominems though.

Dan Svatass
11 days ago

So no response to the substance of my criticism.

Even after the current data, data that was available to you when you published your piece, data that directly undercuts the political attack you tried to make, is put right in your face.

Fair enough, we each get to build our reputations as we see fit.

Mark
8 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Your response had no substance, as Keith has clearly shown.

AK Jarhead
11 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Tell the world you’re a leftist without telling the world you’re a leftist , Karen.

Dan Svatass
10 days ago
Reply to  AK Jarhead

You post that because your preferred truth has been disproven

Truth be damned.

frequencykenny
1 day ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

So in 1 month, 500 people got jobs, folded their tents found apartments and started paying rent? Sure.

Lynn Melland
10 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Homeless as of 1959.

Michael Cipriano
10 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

2,457 seems like a big number as well. Lafrance is 2 months in so her policies really haven’t taken effect yet. Giving her credit for the reduction seems misplaced. I am rooting for her and the assembly. I also would emphatically agree with Keith on a couple points; winter is approaching, and the administration/assembly’s plan is not well fleshed out and funded.

Dan Svatass
9 days ago

I agree with every word.

My focus is on this op-ed, and the author’s purposeful decision not to use current data, to make Mayor LaFrance and our Assembly appear ineffective.

He failed.

Berris Joseph
8 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

There is a problem. We must stop argue about it and aim at solving it. The homeless cry out to their fellow humans every day as the are seen together sharing their bad habits of drinking and eating with each other. If they can be so unified why cannot civilized, sober, and intellige2aant people do this ññp

Bingo Is My Nam-o
11 days ago

Hey !! But we’ve got a brand new Creative Directer fresh out of the Rhode Island School of Design !

Now that’s progress.

debbie nolan
11 days ago

If the homeless use this new 9 million then I suggest this. All homeless in hotel sign over their PFD. Those that get $$ from corporations sign over 1/2 $$$. They have to sign paper in agreement to find work to start at least part time or full time. We cannot keep allowing homeless to abuse the system. Also take $$$ send them back home and have their corps pay to help them. I’m a senior and have been refused snap, medicaid all tge above and and barely hanging on. These homeless in vehicles, have they been checked to have… Read more »

erak
11 days ago
Reply to  debbie nolan

Offer 2 PFDs and a ticket to the L48. They can’t come back unless the pay for the ticket out and 2 PFDs.

Rip
9 days ago
Reply to  debbie nolan

Thank you. I appreciate this logic look at things. It seems to me we aren’t holding anyone accountable for their life choices at all. While some people genuinely find themselves falling on hard times and may need help pulling themselves up by their boot straps. I see the majority of people just abusing the system and refusing to work or help themselves all while committing crimes and making life more difficult for others. The ideology that we all have some sort of obligation to pick up the slack, or to do something to take care of them is infuriating. Your… Read more »

AK Jarhead
11 days ago

Oh weird, liberals running another city into the ground.
Good article brother. Semper Fi

Bill
11 days ago
Reply to  AK Jarhead

This was a very well written article the numbers may not be exactly correct but to most of us the writer point is well taken. SEMPER FI MARINE!

Dan Svatass
10 days ago
Reply to  Bill

Yes, why let actual facts disturb the lie you prefer to believe?

Methinks You Missed The Point
10 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Does 2,457 people instead of 2,940 people make it not a problem?

Dan Svatass
9 days ago

No.

But that reduction is a sign of progress.

Something this author and this website desperately work to deny.

Armywife93
11 days ago

LaFrance and the Assembly should be held accountable. Just going to be another season of wasted money on people that just want something for nothing. Public space is no longer public and most definitely not safe.

David
11 days ago
Reply to  Armywife93

If that’s how you feel file a lawsuit against the city. They have a duty to keep the city safe and public spaces public. Your tax money pays for it.

Yep
11 days ago

They are getting bumped in the meantime.

Reggie Taylor
11 days ago

If the Sullivan Arena costed $1 million per month and hotels cost $9 million per month, why is there any controversy about that balance sheet?

Matt v
11 days ago

So what is the current cost per homeless. I would estimate 300k a year not including emergency services like fire that get dispatched every day. And you think the solution is to spend more .. what is the goal of spending. What is the spending cap. You are suggesting a black hole of cost for drug addicts who do not contribute

You don’t work you don’t eat. We should not sacrifice the community well being for the few

John
10 days ago
Reply to  Matt v

I heard the call as spend smarter, not necessarily more. I hope we can manage to assist a person for less than $300k a year and with less emergency services. Even if that person does not contribute for a long time, or relapses after contributing for a short while, a more organized, long-term approach can cost less. The possibility of actually helping people is just a bonus.

Alitha
11 days ago

Unfortunately, this homeless situation is a problem in this entire country. At the end of the day, allowing property owners to have outrageous rents for properties where the tenants are basically paying the mortgages for these properties seems to not have worked out well for people. if you truly want homelessness to end, stop allowing people to charge almost 70% of somebody’s income for rent. Our local leaders are as much to blame as the leaders in Washington stop talking about it and do something about it. This is Alaska you give away free money every year make it makes… Read more »

Tucker
11 days ago
Reply to  Alitha

So if I buy a duplex to rent out I should rent it out for less than my mortgage? Why would I invest in something to lose money? Makes no sense.

Homelessness is a crime
8 days ago
Reply to  Tucker

Alitha hasnever owned a property

And it shows.

Chris
10 days ago
Reply to  Alitha

As a property owner and landlord, my rent is inflated because I, along with all property owners, pay the taxes which fund this city and support the services. If we shifted the tax burden from property owners to all consumers I wouldn’t have 7k in taxes to extend the cost onto my renters. Sounds like a great idea to implement a consumption tax!

Reggie Taylor
10 days ago
Reply to  Chris

“……..Sounds like a great idea to implement a consumption tax!……..” Do that and I’ll stop buying junk and grow my investments (which does not include real estate; I got out of real estate in this insane state thirty years ago, and that was the best investment decision I ever made). If I stop buying junk, the retail industry hurts. If retail slumps, the transportation industry slumps. Jobs are lost. Catering to people who can’t (or won’t) take care of themselves is always costly. If taken to ridiculous extremes, like socialist government seems intent to do, it can destroy the very… Read more »

Kyle von Bose
11 days ago

Anchorage has had this problem for at least 20 years. If Anchorage is spending this much money a year on this issue it seems like the simplest solution would be to build low/no income efficiency housing for people who need help and stop acting like this is some “Out-of-nowhere disaster” that is being used for a political red herring.

Chiropractic care is an unethical SCAM, so I don’t know why anyone would trust a snake oil salesman to come up with meaningful solutions to a problem he has no business commenting on.

Keith McCormick
11 days ago
Reply to  Kyle von Bose

Who works in chiropractic care?

And who’s allowed to speak on this, is it only the government officials who’ve failed us?

Kyle von Bose
11 days ago

My mistake, my lazy googling found your evil twin who apparently is a chiropractor in Massachusetts.

Reggie Taylor
10 days ago
Reply to  Kyle von Bose

Lousy, wannabe investigators probably have even less authority to fix our social problems than “unethical, snake-oil” chiropractors……….

floridawoman
11 days ago

Not to point out the billion elephants in the room…Keith what would the cost be to implement your solution to homelessness/associated mental health care costs to Anchorage’s homelessness crisis?

Who will pay (full cost will be?) for this solution and how? Property taxes? Sales?

FrankRast
10 days ago

The author complains about the Sully rental fees and then lays blame on the Assembly for not solving a problem that requires $$$$’s. Anchorage has a tax cap with underpaid workers and aging equipment. More State and Federal assistance is needed, not finger pointing.

Dan Svatass
10 days ago
Reply to  FrankRast

The author and this website also have no interest in the underlying data about today’s homeless situation in Anchorage.

Data that destroys the political smear they’re trying to paint.

Justin Michesloff
10 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Dan, The vitriol you so freely spew in your unrequested comments are both sad and unwarranted. You complain loudly about this fine upstanding veterans writing, skewering his facts, but you have failed to do anything about it. May I suggest that you do the deep dive and write your own article with all the” facts” you are so familiar with, submit it for publishing on this very website, then you can educate all of us who share Keith’s view on how we are so wrong. May I suggest that you be very thorough as many of us have already done… Read more »

Dan Svatass
9 days ago

I literally cited and hyperlinked my data, above. To repeat:

“But for some reason, Keith McCormick chose to cite AKHMIS’s homeless count of 2,940 people on July 31. Rather than its most recent count of 2,457 people on August 31.”

“https://www.aceh.org/data”

The rest? lol

Justin Michesloff
9 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

So you didn’t read the response from Keith regarding his usage of the data he did? This brings clearly into focus your true motivations. Regarding your LOL, seriously? You can over comment on another’s article but appear to run the other way when challenged to match and raise. Pathetic.

Reggie Taylor
10 days ago
Reply to  FrankRast

“………More State and Federal assistance is needed………”
The state and feds long ago got out of the business of housing and treating welfare cases, the insane, substance abusers, and now even criminals. This is because the sheer numbers of welfare cases, the insane, substance abusers, and criminals has ballooned beyond any hope of containment and repair. Government isn’t going back because they can’t fix it. Mass media is creating more mental illness daily than any entity can deal with. What you’re faced with is social collapse.

AK Guard guy
10 days ago

Thank you for your article. It’s very accurate with how many of us feel as well. A couple of years ago I submitted a proposal for a recommendation to this homeless crisis before it got this bad. My experience as actually running a village of over 8K Afghans who we migrated to the US as they were being vetted for entry into the states. There were 20+ super tents, medical services, security, supplies, and much more…to include being winterized. This was for people who came to the US with nothing but the clothes on their backs. This number of homeless… Read more »

Dan Svatass
10 days ago
Reply to  AK Guard guy

Those people you were dealing with in Afghanistan and Djibuti:

1. Did not suffer from severe mental illness;
3. Were not suffering from drug and alcohol addiction; and
2. Did not enjoy liberties guaranteed them under the US and Alaska constitutions.

Those complications are significant.

Rick
10 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

Agreed, have them sign contracts free booze, food, and drugs. Could save the city millions per year.

Reggie Taylor
10 days ago
Reply to  Dan Svatass

“……..Those people you were dealing with in Afghanistan and Djibuti:
1. Did not suffer from severe mental illness………
I bet they suffered some serious trauma, PTSD, anxiety, fear, helplessness, and more. Further, a civil war might make the anxiety Americans feel look rather minor, especially if we had a mental health industry that got out of the sex change business and more substance abuse help……..or mandated substance abuse treatment.

Jeff
10 days ago

I am a tourist. Just spent 2 nights and a day in Anchorage at the Hampton Inn. Wife and I walked the 1.5 mile each way to REI store. Unbelievable. So bad on route over there: trash, tents, gangs of people , many high on something. Non-friendly looks as we tried to pass by them on THE PUBLIC SIDEWALKS which they were blocking. We took a different route back, past Walmart. Big mistake! 3 people passed out cold along the sidewalks, LARGER gangs congregating, blocking the sidewalks, and coup de gras was a crazed man running in front of speeding… Read more »

Keith McCormick
10 days ago
Reply to  Jeff

This is the terrible part. The current Anchorage is not the town I grew up in. The last 10-15 years it’s taken a 180. It used to be such a pretty place, safe and serene. Now it’s trash and crime filled and you are scared to walk down the street.

floridawoman
10 days ago

Keith what is your solution to the homeless/mental health crisis in Anchorage, what does it cost to implement these programs, and who is going to pay for it?

floridawoman
9 days ago
Reply to  floridawoman

I get it, it is far easy to be critical of elected officials actions and/or inactions…then to actually offer real solutions with a fiscal plan. Don’t ya think if solving America’s homeless/mental health crisis had an obvious/affordable fix it would have been done already regardless of political affiliation in “power.” Unless of course you have figured it out…please do let us know your plan and the cost? And where the funding will come from. For starters what does a night stay at API cost?

Reggie Taylor
10 days ago
Reply to  Jeff

Welcome to Alaska, Jeff. Too bad you spent it in Anchorage. I’m sorry for your experience. You’re right; you can find that in any city in the Lower 48.

Tucker
9 days ago
Reply to  Jeff

These are truths, not some manipulated data point on a graph.

Chris
8 days ago
Reply to  Jeff

How did you stumble on into website and thread??

Alaskan Lady
6 days ago
Reply to  Jeff

That’s okay, don’t come back. There’s too many out of state people here as it is.

Rip
9 days ago

How about putting the blame on the people who are choosing to put themselves in this situation. Why is it anyone else’s obligation to do something about this.

floridawoman
8 days ago
Reply to  Rip

Because that is why they call it a mental health crisis not just housing crisis…we are all impacted when people with mental health concerns fall through the cracks and end up on the street.

Tucker
8 days ago
Reply to  floridawoman

Ah yes, it’s the flavor of the day. They all have mental illness and addiction issues, therefore it’s not their fault. Somehow it’s the fault of everyone else. Got it.

floridawoman
8 days ago
Reply to  Tucker

You have never seen a homeless person demonstrating signs of schizophrenia? Really? Guess we walk different streets. —- The correlation between mental health concerns and homelessness is not a new correlation or a flavor of the day. There is far more than 40 years of research on the subject. —- No one is saying homelessness is everyone’s else’s fault, but jailing people for being mentally ill (cruelness aside) comes with a heavy cost…so what does your solution cost and who is going to pay for it? Say we just jail all of anchorage’s homeless? Is that your solution (liberty/compassion/etc aside)… Read more »

Tucker
7 days ago
Reply to  floridawoman

Not all 2000+ have mental illness. Yes, there is a group that does but there are many who are just flat out criminals. If theise folks were off the street it’d be easier to want to help those who truly need it.

floridawoman
6 days ago
Reply to  Tucker

What will it cost to jail/treat >2000 people and who will pay for it? What is the Alaska jail empty bed capacity?

erak
5 days ago
Reply to  floridawoman

Never know until we try. Jail a few of the more egregious campers. Word will get out, causing many to seek legal shelter. As for cost, I think jail is probably the most expensive alternative. Karluk Manor houses people who drink. Never here anything bad about the place. Wonder how much it costs per resident.